Denotified, Semi-Nomadic, and Nomadic Tribes: A Comprehensive Analysis

Context:

In a landmark move, the Government of India has undertaken a comprehensive categorization of 268 denotified, semi-nomadic, and nomadic tribes (DNTs, SNTs, and NTs) after a three-year study. The categorization has led to significant developments:

Inclusion of 179 communities in the SC, ST, and OBC lists.
First-time classification of 85 communities.
63 communities identified as untraceable due to assimilation, migration, or name changes.

This move addresses a long-standing issue faced by these communities, who have historically suffered from exclusion in welfare schemes and reservation benefits. The initiative is expected to streamline policy interventions and facilitate social justice.

Admission Open for PARIKSHA [UPSC Prelims Batch] Starts from 27th January 2025: https://bit.ly/4jciwCi

Introduction to Denotified, Semi-Nomadic, and Nomadic Tribes (DNTs, SNTs, NTs)
Historical Context
Current Categorization and Its Significance
Demographics and Socio-Economic Status
Challenges Faced by DNTs
Government Interventions and Welfare Schemes
Political Debate and Policy Considerations
Comparative Analysis: Global Perspective on Nomadic and Indigenous Tribes
Way Forward
Conclusion

1. Introduction to Denotified, Semi-Nomadic, and Nomadic Tribes

Denotified, Semi-Nomadic, and Nomadic Tribes (DNTs) are among the most marginalized communities in India, often living on the fringes of society. They comprise around 10 crore people, yet lack recognition and access to government benefits. These communities include Banjara, Gujjar, Pardhi, Nat, Kanjar, among others, and can be broadly classified as:

Denotified Tribes (DNTs): Declared “criminal tribes” by the British but decriminalized after independence (post-1952).
Nomadic Tribes (NTs): Communities traditionally dependent on mobile livelihoods like animal husbandry, craft, and trade.
Semi-Nomadic Tribes (SNTs): Groups transitioning towards settled lifestyles but retaining some nomadic practices.

2. Historical Context

Criminal Tribes Act, 1871 & 1924-

The British colonial administration classified several communities as ‘criminal tribes’, subjecting them to surveillance, forced resettlement, and restrictions on movement.
The Criminal Tribes Act, 1924 expanded these classifications, increasing social stigma and economic hardship.

Denotification and Subsequent Developments-

1949: The Criminal Tribes Act was repealed, and the affected communities were denotified.
1955: Kalelkar Commission highlighted their socio-economic backwardness.
1965: Lokur Committee recommended their inclusion in SC/ST lists.
1980: Mandal Commission studied their status and recommended OBC status for some groups.
2008: Renke Commission found that 97% of DNTs live in abject poverty.
2017: Idate Commission identified 1,200 tribes, out of which 267 were unclassified.

3. Current Categorization and Its Significance

First comprehensive effort post-Independence to categorize these tribes.
Expected to streamline welfare programs and reservations.
Facilitates state-level policy implementation.

Challenges:

Activists argue against their inclusion in SC/ST/OBC categories, fearing dilution of reservation benefits.
Demand for a separate constitutional schedule for DNTs.

4. Demographics and Socio-Economic Status

Population: ~10 crore people.
Literacy Rate: Below 30% in many regions (National Average: 77.7%).
Land Ownership: Less than 10% of DNTs own land.
Health Indicators: High child mortality and malnutrition rates.
Political Representation: Marginalized in mainstream politics.

5. Challenges Faced by DNTs

Exclusion from Welfare Schemes-

Many DNTs remain unrecognized in SC/ST/OBC lists, barring them from reservations and social welfare benefits.

Social Stigma and Criminalization-

Often still labeled as ‘criminal tribes’, leading to harassment by law enforcement.

Economic and Educational Barriers-

High dropout rates due to lack of school access.
Low employment due to discrimination.

6. Government Interventions and Welfare Schemes

Scheme	Year	Focus Area
SEED Scheme	2022	Education, Employment, Health, Housing
NCDNT Commission	2014	Policy Implementation
Vimukta Jati Development Corporation	State-Level	Financial Assistance
PM Van Dhan Yojana	Ongoing	Livelihood Generation

Daily Current Affairs available here: https://bit.ly/3C4SAYw

7. Political Debate and Policy Considerations

Activists argue for a separate category instead of SC/ST/OBC classification.
State governments can now facilitate better inclusion in welfare programs.

8. Global Perspective on Nomadic and Indigenous Tribes

Roma in Europe: Face discrimination similar to DNTs.
Maasai in Africa: Struggle with land rights and identity.
Native Americans: Fought for legal recognition and reservation rights.

9. Way Forward

Unified Categorization: Clear classification in reservation lists.
Tailored Welfare Programs: Education, healthcare, financial support.
Social Awareness Campaigns: Reduce stigma through education.
Land and Housing Reforms: Secure land rights for economic stability.

10. Conclusion

DNTs have long been one of India’s most marginalized communities. The recent categorization is a significant step, but more needs to be done to ensure social justice and inclusion. A focused policy approach and strong political will are necessary for their upliftment.