Admissions Open for the 2026 Self-Study Plan. Enroll Now!
+91 - 7893910103 support@upscguide.in

Supreme Court Directive on Sacred Groves: A Detailed Analysis

img

 

The Supreme Court’s recent directive mandating Rajasthan’s Forest Department to classify sacred groves as ‘forests’ and ‘community reserves’ under the Wildlife Protection Act (WLPA) has sparked significant debate. The order overrides the provisions of the Forest Rights Act (FRA) 2006, which had previously granted rights to local communities for managing these groves.

This decision has far-reaching consequences for environmental conservation, community-led governance, and indigenous rights, making it a critical topic for the UPSC Civil Services Examination.

 

 

PARIKSHA -Open Mock Test on 8th February,2025

 

Join Telegram Channel for daily updates

 

Table of Contents:

  1. Introduction

  2. Sacred Groves: An Overview

  3. Supreme Court Order: Key Highlights

  4. Legal and Constitutional Aspects

  5. Impact on Community Rights and Local Governance

  6. Environmental Significance of Sacred Groves

  7. Cultural and Religious Significance

  8. Concerns Over the Supreme Court Order

  9. Comparative Analysis with Global Practices

  10. Way Forward: Policy and Legal Suggestions

  11. Conclusion

 

NCERTs Foundation Batch for UPSC

 
Introduction:

 

Relevance to UPSC Exam-

  • GS Paper 1 (Indian Heritage and Culture): Traditional conservation practices, religious and cultural dimensions of sacred groves.

  • GS Paper 2 (Governance & Law): Legal implications, FRA vs. WLPA, role of the judiciary in environmental governance.

  • GS Paper 3 (Environment & Ecology): Biodiversity, forest conservation policies, climate change impact, community-led conservation models.

  • Essay Paper: Ethical and governance dimensions in balancing environmental protection with human rights.

 
Sacred Groves: An Overview:

 

Definition and Concept-

Sacred groves are patches of forest protected by local communities due to religious and cultural beliefs. These groves are considered abodes of deities, spirits, or ancestors, and their preservation is deeply rooted in traditional knowledge systems.

 

Historical Significance-

  • Sacred groves have existed for thousands of years, with references in ancient texts such as the Rigveda and Upanishads.

  • They were historically managed by local communities, ensuring sustainable conservation.

 

Sacred Groves in Different States-

  • -Devrai (Maharashtra)

  • Devarakadu (Karnataka)

  • Jaherthan (Jharkhand)

  • Kavu (Kerala)

  • Sarna (Chhattisgarh, Jharkhand)

 

Supreme Court Order: Key Highlights:

 

Directives Issued-

  • Sacred groves to be mapped and classified as ‘forests’.

  • Management shifted from communities to state authorities.

  • Protection under Wildlife Protection Act (WLPA).

 

Impact on Local Communities-

  • Loss of autonomy over their sacred lands.

  • Restrictions on traditional rights.

  • Possible displacement and loss of cultural identity.

 

Shift of Control to State-

  • Bureaucratic hurdles in forest governance.

  • Possibility of commercial exploitation under state control.

 

Legal and Constitutional Aspects:

 

Forest Conservation Laws in India-

  1. Wildlife Protection Act (WLPA), 1972

  2. Forest Conservation Act, 1980

  3. Forest Rights Act (FRA), 2006

  4. Biodiversity Act, 2002

 

Conflict Between FRA and WLPA-

  • FRA 2006 grants community forest rights.

  • WLPA prioritizes state-led conservation.

  • SC order favors state control over community rights.

 

Key Supreme Court Cases Related to Forests-

  • T.N. Godavarman v. Union of India (1996): Expanded the definition of forests.

  • Niyamgiri Case (2013): Recognized tribal rights over forests.

 

Impact on Community Rights and Local Governance

 

Traditional Conservation Practices-

  • Community-led sustainable management.

  • Rituals and taboos ensuring protection.

 

Role of Gram Sabhas-

  • Decision-making authority over local resources.

  • FRA empowers Gram Sabhas, but SC order undermines their role.

 

Bureaucratic Challenges and Legal Hurdles-

  • Complex approvals and state interventions.

  • Local resistance to state control.

 

Environmental Significance of Sacred Groves:

 

Biodiversity Hotspots and Wildlife Protection-

  • Sacred groves harbor rare and endemic species.

 

Carbon Sequestration and Climate Change Mitigation-

  • Act as carbon sinks, reducing CO2 levels.

 

Role in Water Conservation-

  • Maintain local hydrological cycles.

  • Prevent soil erosion and drought.

 

Examples and Case Studies-

  • Kodagu Sacred Groves (Karnataka) – Biodiversity conservation.

  • Sundarbans Mangrove Forests – Climate resilience.

 

Way Forward: Policy and Legal Suggestions:

 

Need for Legal Reconciliation

  • Harmonizing FRA and WLPA provisions.

 

Strengthening Decentralized Governance

  • Involvement of local communities in decision-making.

 

Role of Judiciary in Sustainable Forest Management

  • Ensuring balanced conservation and community rights.

 
Conclusion

The SC order is a double-edged sword, prioritizing conservation but undermining community rights. A balanced approach integrating legal, ecological, and social dimensions is essential for sustainable forest governance in India.

 

Daily Current Affairs available here: https://bit.ly/3C4SAYw